Politici promossi e bocciati Who comes out victorious from the 'last crisis?
The building of proceedings. Let the votes Italian politicians
Berlusconi rejected for only three votes in the assault at the ends of the former. But suffice? And how they have behaved the other party leaders? We asked some top experts. Here are their report cards
Marianna Aprile, Gino Gullace Raugei, Mauro Suttora
Today, December 29, 2010
seemed that the fate of Italy as a whole should be decided on December 14: After months of increasingly bitter disputes, the split between Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi and that the House has landed in Parliament. The vote confidence in the government was hanging by a thread, because the former deputies who followed Fini PDL was almost 40.
eventually won Berlusconi, and the government remained in office. But only three votes. The margin in favor was obtained through deserters from Pd (Calearo Massimo and Bruno Cesario), Italy of Values \u200b\u200b(Antonio Razzi, Domenico Scilipoti), and the votes of two Finian repent, Catia Polidori and Maria Grazia Siliquini.
But how they have behaved in this major Italian political crisis and, more generally, in 2010?
Today, with the help of renowned experts gave their report cards. And now, dear readers, it's up to you: Go and vote on our website www.oggi.it.
Silvio Berlusconi: 7. "It's steel," said Stefano Folli, a columnist for the
Sole 24 Ore, "has demonstrated the ability to re-emerge with skills and ruthlessness to be a serious difficulty." "I give him 10 for the management of the crisis, a ruling as to" specific Piero Ignatius, commentator of 'Espresso
. "In the 'last month was very good," adds Pierluigi Battista, a columnist for the Corriere della Sera
: "It was hidden and has to make its recruitment of members willing to betray their mandate: to be an alternative to Berlusconi. Flawless tactics, combined with the ability to take advantage of the catastrophic mistakes of others. "
Giorgio Napolitano: 8. "Institutional", praises the Baptist. Ignazi agrees: "It was an impartial management in the interests of the country."
Antonio Di Pietro: 5. Crowd: "Shallow. Dall'Idv came the decisive defections. He is responsible for a bad choice of its parliamentarians. " Ignatius: "Pull the rope too, is vulgar. Est modus in rebus. It makes the game Cicchitti. And in his party's bad apples. " Baptist: "No one would ever surrounded by Robespierre Scilipoti ..." Marco Travaglio (
The Done), "Worth eight for the opposition, is the only one who does it seriously, but four proposals for the part. His eternal Achilles heel is the inability to choose collaborators height. In some cases favors dark shady dealer in the suburbs, claiming to packets of votes. "
Gianfranco Fini: 5. Crowd: "hasty. He had the merit of establishing itself as an alternative to Berlusconi, but then the wrong strategy. " Ignatius: "In the end he failed. And the result is what counts in politics. " Marcello Sorgi, a columnist for La Stampa de
: "He's the real loser, because he had committed all his forces on the objective failure of 'killing of Berlusconi, and then had to repair under the protective wing of Casini. Baptist: "He deserved 10 for the resilience of the campaign of annihilation dei berlusconiani. Ma avrebbe dovuto logorare Berlusconi, non cercare la frattura. È una disfatta politica, non numerica, la sua».
Roberto Maroni: 5,5. Battista: «La Lega Nord ha rafforzato l'asse con Berlusconi, ma non ha avuto quel che voleva: le elezioni. Almeno non per ora». Ignazi: «Ha confuso i ruoli di ministro dell'Interno (bravo) e capo della Lega, pretendendo la replica nel programma tv di Fazio e Saviano».
Sandro Bondi: 4. Battista: «Assente, perché in visita a Pompei...»
Paolo Guzzanti: 5. Battista: «Non poteva che votare contro Berlusconi, dopo aver firmato la mozione di sfiducia e scritto il libro
Mignottocrazia ».
Gianni Letta: 8. As always, wisely treated and stitched up in the shadows. "But this time it well focused on the subject of mediation," says Battista. "Too defiladed to judge," adds Ignazi.
Umberto Bossi: 7. "Bravo and sly," praises Ignazi. Pier Ferdinando Casini
: 7. Arise, "Casini Berlusconi had asked for no confidence, and is among the losers. However, Berlusconi's reserves the right to make the partners to strengthen the 'weak majority. " Crowd: "It was relocated as a privileged interlocutor of the center." Baptist: "He has regained the center of downtown."
Italo Bocchino: 4. Folli: «Avventuroso. Il suo discorso finale alla Camera ha danneggiato molto Fini». Non concorda Ignazi: «È stato bravo a fare quel che voleva il suo capo». Battista: «Dò 9 a Bocchino, ma solo in audience. Prima nessuno sapeva chi fosse».
Daniela Santanchè: 5. Ignazi: «No comment. Ma stiamo parlando di politica?» Battista: «Dovrebbe smettere di imitare la Cortellesi che imita lei. Il ruolo di supercattiva ha stancato».
Catia Polidori e Maria Grazia Siliquini: 4. Le due deputate finiane tornate all'ovile berlusconiano non riscuotono grande simpatia. Battista scherza: «Soddisfatte e rimborsate».
Pier Luigi Bersani: 5,5. Folli: «Poco relevant. He failed to make clear opposition to the proposal. Transitional government and national responsibility: the two forms have not been clarified. " Ignatius: "It's the talk by reading the leaflet, as the provincial Communist Party bureaucrats." Travaglio: "line wavering, to the limits incomprehensibility." "But I think he behaved well," says Conchita De Gregorio, head of the Unit
. "Most of what he did could not do. Some people screaming and who opposes it, as Bersani, demonstrates the fact that Berlusconi is not able to advance the country ". Roberto Bernabo, director of the Tyrrhenian
"Bersani comes from ' latest crisis a bit 'more than the big historical leader of his party. But Berlusconi's victory is not enough evidence that Palazzo operations to overthrow the PDL. "
Massimo D 'Alema: 5. Baptist jokes: "It was the great strategist of defeat. So he won. "
Mariastella Gelmini: 5. Ignatius: "All things which are bad." Baptist: "The reform of the 'university is not evil, in the' merit system. But it was risky to expose the 'outcome to the crisis and political balance, moving the debate in the Senate after the distrust. "
and Domenico Antonio Razzi Scilipoti: 4. I DiPietro who saved Berlusconi rejected. Baptist "Scilipoti is the archetype, the model. When he explained the reasons for his choice seemed to Breton, it was surreal, beyond comprehension. "
Silvano Moffa: 4. He betrayed twice: first by going with Fini Berlusconi, Fini and Berlusconi returned.
Massimo Calearo: 2. "His case is far more serious than that of DiPietro turncoat," says Travaglio, "because the former chairman of the Democratic Party leaders had even Federmeccanica veltroni in Veneto and in 2008 it was clear that he was a fish out of water: a industrial "hawk" of Confindustria in a center-left party could only be an infiltrator Berlusconi, which later proved to be just grabbed Deputies to the chair. "
Walter Veltroni: 5. Ignatius: "He did elect Calearo. Baptist jokes: "You should rewrite the final chapter of his book We, titling them".
Matteo Renzi: 5. Ignatius: "The mayor of Florence, it seems to me a narcissist overflowing, so much to be confused with Berlusconi."
Rosi Bindi: 6. Ignatius: "The only left with clear ideas. And do not use the political jargon to express them. "
Marco Pannella: 5. Ignatius: "His" negotiations "with Mr Berlusconi has been a botched provocation."
Ignazio La Russa: 5. "But as Defense Minister is acceptable," says Ignazi.
Francesco Rutelli: 5. Arise, "the third pole with Casini, Fini and Williams wants to stop the bleeding of parliamentarians to Berlusconi's center. Rutelli also hoped that the former reach the Pd dc dissatisfied with the ex-communist alliance. "
Our experts have given 7 to Nichi Vendola. "It's good, capable, charming, innovative," says Piero Ignazi. And he says Bernabo, director of the Tyrrhenian
: "It has many chances to win the primaries of the center, if there are. Else then win the election, in which also serves as the moderate vote. "
Mara Carfagna, 35, minister for equal opportunities, worth 5.5. Piero Ignatius: "I do not we expected a lot from her, but it is decent in a devastating scene of desolation. " Pierluigi Battista joked, referring to his push and pull between Berlusconi and Mouthpiece: "Worth ten vaulting."
The Treasury Minister Giulio Tremonti has remained silent. "He has not done anything," says Piero Ignazi. "It's building a 'political image as a prelude to a future role." And the Baptist: "He was absent because he pledged to keep the cash."
